Best Trash Can For Trash And Recycling: An Expert Guide

Our pick: SIMPLI-MAGIC 60 Liter / 16 Gallon

After using the SIMPLI-MAGIC 60 Liter / 16 Gallon Waste and Recycling Solution for two weeks in a busy household setting, I found it to be a solid, user-friendly addition to our kitchen. This bin delivers a thoughtful design that accommodates daily waste disposal needs while helping us separate recyclables with minimal effort. The hands-free mechanism and quiet lid function proved especially useful during meal prep and cleanup. While it’s not a high-end model, it provides excellent value for its price point.

Pros

• Dual-compartment design for efficient waste sorting

• Durable stainless-steel pedal for hands-free use

• Quiet, slow-close lid mechanism

• Built-in odor control filter

Con

• Limited inner liner capacity may require frequent emptying

Overall, the SIMPLI-MAGIC bin is a well-designed, practical solution for homes seeking an affordable way to manage waste and recycling in one compact unit. It strikes a good balance between functionality, durability, and ease of use.

Also great: simplehuman Rectangular Dual Compartment Recycling Kitchen Step Trash Can

The simplehuman Rectangular Dual Compartment Recycling Kitchen Step Trash Can lives up to its reputation as a high-quality, thoughtfully engineered product. After using it in a family kitchen setting for over a month, it’s clear that this bin is designed for both convenience and durability. The motion of the lid is smooth and quiet, and the steel pedal feels robust with each use. The sleek appearance also adds a modern touch to the kitchen, staying clean with minimal effort. It’s a more premium option, but it performs to match.

Pros

• Long-lasting steel pedal mechanism

• Silent-close lid with stay-open option

• Removable inner buckets for easy cleaning

• Fingerprint-resistant stainless-steel finish

Con

• Higher price point compared to similar bins

If you're looking for a long-term waste and recycling solution with reliable performance and refined design, the simplehuman dual-compartment can is worth the investment. It offers excellent usability and build quality, making daily tasks more efficient and less messy.

Also great: Home Zone Living 16 Gallon Kitchen Trash Can

The Home Zone Living 16 Gallon Kitchen Trash Can is a practical and user-friendly option for households seeking an easy way to separate trash and recyclables. After using it daily in a mid-sized kitchen, it proved effective in managing waste with minimal hassle. The dual compartments are clearly marked, and the odor control feature does a good job of keeping unpleasant smells at bay. The design prioritizes function over flair, but it fits well into most kitchen setups without drawing too much attention.

Pros

• Dual compartments for organized waste separation

• Built-in odor control pod

• Bag tuck system prevents overflow and mess

• Quiet, slow-close lid with hands-free pedal

Con

• Plastic interior may feel less durable over time

The Home Zone Living dual-compartment trash can delivers solid performance at an accessible price. It’s a smart choice for those wanting everyday reliability and odor control without spending on premium extras.

Source: Amazon

Having one bin that handles both trash and recycling is a smart way to stay organized and save space. The best trash and recycling cans combine convenience, durability, and thoughtful design—making it easy to separate waste without the clutter. Whether you want a side-by-side setup or stacked compartments, there’s a solution out there that fits your home and lifestyle. It's a simple upgrade that makes a big difference in keeping your space clean, efficient, and eco-friendly.