10 Best Toasted Sandwich Maker of 2025, Tested by Experts

Source: Amazon

Our pick: Hamilton Beach Panini Press Sandwich Maker

The Hamilton Beach Panini Press and Sandwich Maker (Model 25460AG) is a practical, no-frills appliance designed for everyday use. Its floating lid adjusts to various food thicknesses, making it versatile enough for paninis, burgers, quesadillas, and more. The 8" x 10" nonstick grill plates heat evenly and clean up easily, while the chrome finish adds a simple, modern look. With its 180-degree open-flat design, it doubles as an indoor grill. A locking lid and compact build make it easy to store. Ideal for quick meals and casual cooking without the need for a full-size grill.

Also great: BLACK+DECKER 3-in-1 Waffle Iron, WM2000SD

The BLACK+DECKER 3-in-1 Waffle Iron WM2000SD is a compact, versatile kitchen tool designed for everyday convenience. With interchangeable, non-stick plates, it easily switches between waffle maker, grill, and sandwich press modes—ideal for quick breakfasts or light lunches. The plates are dishwasher-safe and feature grease run-off channels for cleaner, lower-fat cooking. Cool-touch handles and indicator lights add to the safety and ease of use. Its stainless steel accents and space-saving design make it a sleek fit for any kitchen.

Also great: Chefman Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker

The Chefman Panini Press Grill is a practical and flexible option for quick meals at home or on the go. Its 4-slice capacity and floating hinge allow it to handle everything from thin sandwiches to thick paninis, while the 180-degree open feature transforms it into a grill for burgers, vegetables, and more. The non-stick plates and removable drip tray make cleanup fast and easy. With compact dimensions, it fits well in tight spaces like dorms or small kitchens. Stainless steel accents and thoughtful features—like skid-resistant feet and grease drainage—round out a user-friendly design built for daily use.

• Toast Maker: Generally refers to a device specifically designed to toast bread slices evenly.

• Sandwich Maker: Has plates that seal the edges of sandwiches while toasting them, creating a compact, sealed sandwich.

What is the best all-in-one sandwich maker?

The best all-in-one sandwich maker combines features of both a sandwich maker and a grill:

• Interchangeable Plates: Allows for switching between flat plates for sandwiches and ridged plates for grilling.
• Adjustable Temperature Control: Offers flexibility in cooking various types of food.
• Easy to Clean: Non-stick plates and removable trays simplify cleanup.
• Compact Design: Suitable for smaller kitchens or dorm rooms.

What is the difference between a toastie and a toasted sandwich?

In essence, "toastie" and "toasted sandwich" are often used interchangeably and refer to a sandwich that has been toasted or grilled. However, in some contexts:

• Toastie: Can imply a sandwich made in a dedicated toastie maker with sealed edges.
• Toasted Sandwich: May refer more broadly to any sandwich that has been toasted or grilled, including those made in a toaster or on a grill.

What toastie maker doesn't leak?

To prevent leaks in a toastie maker:

• Seal Design: Opt for models with a secure seal around the edges.
• Non-Stick Plates: Helps to keep ingredients intact and easy to clean.
• Adjustable Hinges: Ensures even pressure for a tight seal.

What do Australians call toasted sandwiches?

In Australia, toasted sandwiches are commonly referred to as "toasties." This term is widely used to describe sandwiches that have been toasted or grilled, often in a dedicated toastie maker with sealed edges.

Related Posts: 

The Best Sandwich Grillers Of 2025

Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Maker: An Expert Guide

10 Best Grill Sandwich Maker, Tested & Review

The Best Waffle And Sandwich Maker, Top Choices