The 10 Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports, According to Experts

Our pick: Ninja NC501 CREAMi Deluxe

The Ninja CREAMi Deluxe Ice Cream & Frozen Treat Maker (NC501) delivers a significantly upgraded experience compared to earlier models. With an expanded 11-in-1 functionality and XL 24 oz. tubs, it’s designed for families and frozen treat enthusiasts who want more variety, capacity, and customization. From ice cream and sorbet to milkshakes and protein-packed desserts, this machine offers consistent results and broad versatility, making it one of the most advanced home-use frozen dessert makers currently available.

During testing, the machine impressed with its ease of use, delivering smooth textures and full-bodied flavors even with dairy-free or low-sugar recipes. The new dual processing option also allows users to create layered mix-in experiences, offering an extra level of personalization that sets it apart from basic ice cream makers.

Pros

• 11-in-1 functionality with 5 added programs for expanded treat options

• XL 24 oz. tubs for larger batch preparation

• Dual processing for separate mix-in flavor layers

• Customization for dietary needs (low sugar, high protein, vegan, dairy-free)

Cons

• Only compatible with NC500 series tubs

• Requires overnight freezing before processing

The Ninja CREAMi Deluxe NC501 is an excellent choice for households looking to create a wide range of frozen treats with ease and flexibility. With advanced features and increased capacity, it caters to both creativity and convenience. Overall, it's a top-tier ice cream maker that justifies its premium positioning.

Source: Amazon

Also great: IcyTreat Ice Cream Maker Machine

The IcyTreat 12-in-1 Ice Cream Maker brings professional-level frozen dessert making to your kitchen, thanks to its advanced Ic-Vortex technology and wide range of one-touch programs. Designed for families and health-conscious users alike, this fully automatic machine offers customization across a variety of dietary preferences including vegan, keto, and sugar-free. With powerful performance, thoughtful features, and user-friendly operation, the IcyTreat stands out as a serious contender in the home ice cream maker market.

From first use, the machine proves itself capable of delivering creamy, scoopable textures across its 12 preset programs. The inclusion of three family-sized tubs means there's always room to experiment or prepare enough for everyone. Its standout cleaning design and accessories package round out a well-thought-out offering.

Pros

• 12 one-touch programs covering a wide variety of frozen treats

• Fully removable stainless steel blade system for deep cleaning

• Customizable options across 8 dietary recipe categories

• Powerful Ic-Vortex technology ensures smooth, consistent results

Cons

• Requires overnight freezing before churning

• Slightly bulky footprint for smaller kitchens

The IcyTreat 12-in-1 Ice Cream Maker delivers exceptional versatility and premium performance for homemade frozen desserts. Whether you're aiming for classic scoops or specialized dietary recipes, it offers ease of use without sacrificing quality. A smart investment for families or dessert enthusiasts seeking variety and control in every batch.

Also great: Whynter ICM-201SB Upright

The Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Qt. Ice Cream Maker stands out with its self-refrigerating compressor system, removing the need for pre-freezing and offering consistent, on-demand frozen treats. Praised by America's Test Kitchen as the best in its category, this model caters to serious home dessert makers looking for speed, convenience, and high-quality results. With its sleek stainless steel design, intuitive LCD panel, and continuous-use capability, it's a reliable workhorse for anyone who wants to skip the planning and get straight to churning.

In testing, the machine delivered rich, creamy textures in under an hour with minimal setup. The extended cooling function helps maintain consistency, while the built-in safety features offer peace of mind for long-term use. It’s particularly ideal for users who make frozen treats frequently and want more flexibility than freezer bowl models allow.

Pros

• Built-in compressor allows for no pre-freezing and continuous use

• 2.1-quart capacity makes large batches for families or gatherings

• Extended cooling and motor protection functions enhance durability

• Sleek design with user-friendly LCD display and timer

Cons

• Higher upfront cost compared to non-compressor models

• Larger footprint may not suit compact kitchens

The Whynter ICM-201SB is a top-tier, self-cooling ice cream maker designed for performance, convenience, and style. Its ability to make multiple batches back-to-back without freezing prep sets it apart. For serious dessert enthusiasts or frequent entertainers, this machine is well worth the investment.

The top-rated ice cream maker varies depending on individual preferences and needs. However, one consistently well-regarded option is the Cuisinart ICE-30BC Pure Indulgence 2-Quart Automatic Frozen Yogurt, Sorbet, and Ice Cream Maker. It's praised for its ease of use, large capacity, and consistent results.

Is it worth buying an ice cream maker?

Investing in an ice cream maker can be worthwhile for those who enjoy homemade frozen treats and value customization. With an ice cream maker, you have complete control over ingredients, allowing you to create healthier options or cater to specific dietary restrictions. Additionally, it can be a fun activity for families or individuals passionate about experimenting with flavors.

Why is the Ninja Creami so popular?

The Ninja Creami has gained popularity due to its versatility and innovative features. Unlike traditional ice cream makers, the Ninja Creami not only churns ice cream but also allows users to create a variety of frozen treats, including smoothies, milkshakes, and even doughs for baked goods. Its ability to quickly whip up frozen desserts and its range of functions make it a favorite among consumers seeking versatility in their kitchen appliances.

What are the different types of ice cream makers?

There are several types of ice cream makers available, each with its own advantages and drawbacks:

1. Manual Ice Cream Makers: These require manual effort to churn the ice cream mixture, typically with a hand crank or by shaking the container.

2. Electric Ice Cream Makers: These automate the churning process, making it easier and more convenient to create homemade ice cream.

3. Compressor Ice Cream Makers: These machines have a built-in freezer, eliminating the need for pre-freezing the bowl or container, making them ideal for frequent use.

4. Freezer Bowl Ice Cream Makers: These utilize a double-walled bowl that must be pre-frozen before use, which can be limiting for those who want to make multiple batches in quick succession.

5. Soft Serve Ice Cream Makers: Designed to produce a softer, creamier texture, these machines are commonly found in commercial settings but are also available for home use.

What are the top 5 ice cream makers?

1. Cuisinart ICE-30BC Pure Indulgence: Known for its reliability and large capacity, this electric ice cream maker is favored by many home chefs.

2. Ninja Creami: Popular for its versatility, the Ninja Creami not only churns ice cream but also makes a variety of frozen treats, making it a versatile addition to any kitchen.

3. Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop: This compressor ice cream maker offers 12 hardness settings and a self-refrigerating compressor, allowing for precise control over texture and consistency.

4. KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment: Designed to be used with KitchenAid stand mixers, this attachment is convenient for those who already own the compatible appliance and want to save space.

5. Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE Vintage Collection: This manual ice cream maker adds a nostalgic touch to the ice cream-making experience and is favored by those who enjoy a more traditional approach to homemade treats.

Related Posts:

• 10 Best Ice Cream Maker, Best Models
• The Best Small Ice Cream Machine, Buyer’s Guide
• Top 10 Best Rated Electric Ice Cream Maker Reviewed
• 10 Best Professional Ice Cream Machine, Ranked By Experts