10 Best Club Soda, Ranked by Experts

Our pick: Fever-Tree Club Soda - Premium Quality Mixer

Having tested Fever-Tree Club Soda across a variety of cocktails and non-alcoholic mocktails, I found it to be a standout mixer that delivers both in taste and consistency. The carbonation is exceptionally fine and long-lasting, which enhances the drinking experience without overpowering other ingredients. It’s clear this soda was crafted with mixology in mind.

The ingredients list is clean—no artificial sweeteners or colors—and it shows in the pure, refreshing taste. Whether used as a base in a gin and tonic or simply served over ice with a splash of citrus, it adds a subtle mineral edge without any bitterness. Its versatility and premium quality make it a worthwhile choice for home bartenders and casual consumers alike.

Pros

• Clean, natural flavor profile

• Persistent, fine carbonation

• No artificial ingredients

• Excellent packaging for freshness

Cons

• Higher price point than standard club sodas

• Limited availability in some local stores

Fever-Tree Club Soda is a premium mixer that lives up to its reputation. While it may come at a slightly higher price, the quality and experience it provides more than justify the cost. A top-tier choice for those serious about their drinks.

Also great: Pacific Sea Salt Club Soda, Regatta Craft Mixers

Regatta Craft Mixers’ Pacific Sea Salt Club Soda is a zero-calorie, all-natural option that strikes a great balance between functionality and flavor. After testing it in both spirit-based and alcohol-free drinks, I found it to be a reliable and versatile mixer that brings a light mineral twist without overwhelming the drink. Its subtle sea salt note adds depth, making it stand out among other club sodas.

Packaged in sleek 7.5oz mini cans, it's a convenient, portion-controlled option—great for casual home use or entertaining without waste. The carbonation is lively but not overly aggressive, and it holds up well when poured over ice or mixed into cocktails. This soda plays well in simple serves like a vodka soda or a more complex cocktail with herbal or citrus elements.

Pros

• Zero calories with natural ingredients

• Subtle sea salt enhances flavor complexity

• Convenient single-serve mini cans

• Balanced carbonation for versatile mixing

Cons

• Smaller cans may not suit every use

• Sea salt flavor may not appeal to all tastes

Regatta’s Pacific Sea Salt Club Soda is a thoughtful, well-crafted mixer that offers convenience and character. Its clean profile and natural ingredients make it a solid pick for health-conscious consumers or anyone looking to elevate their cocktail game with ease.

Also great: Canada Dry Club Soda Soft Drink

Canada Dry Club Soda is a classic, no-frills option that’s long been a staple in homes and bars alike. After testing it in a variety of drinks—from highballs to mocktails—it proves to be a dependable and refreshing mixer. Its carbonation is moderate, providing enough lift to enhance a drink without becoming too fizzy or flat too quickly.

The flavor profile is neutral with a clean finish, making it a solid background player that won’t compete with spirits or mixers. While it doesn’t offer any distinct mineral notes or artisanal touches, it delivers on consistency and value, especially when purchased in bulk.

Pros

• Clean, neutral flavor suitable for all mixers

• Widely available and budget-friendly

• Good carbonation retention

• Versatile 12-ounce can size

Cons

• Lacks unique or elevated flavor profile

• Contains no added minerals or natural enhancements

Canada Dry Club Soda offers great value and reliable performance. While it may not cater to craft cocktail enthusiasts seeking premium mixers, it’s a go-to for those who want a straightforward, refreshing club soda that gets the job done every time.

Source: Amazon

A good club soda is typically characterized by its clean, crisp taste and balanced carbonation. Some popular and high-quality club sodas include:

• Schweppes Club Soda: A classic choice with a well-balanced flavor and reliable carbonation.
• Canada Dry Club Soda: Known for its smooth taste and consistent bubbles.
• Q Club Soda: Offers a premium option with natural ingredients and a clean, refreshing taste.
• Fever-Tree Club Soda: Made with natural spring water and a hint of quinine for a more sophisticated flavor.

These club sodas are ideal for mixing in cocktails due to their clean taste and effervescence.

What is the Best Club Soda for Aperol?

For mixing with Aperol, a club soda with a clean and crisp taste works best to balance the slightly bitter and citrusy notes of Aperol. Fever-Tree Club Soda is a great choice due to its natural spring water and subtle quinine flavor, which complements the Aperol without overpowering it. Another excellent option is Schweppes Club Soda, known for its reliable carbonation and neutral flavor.

What is the Best Club Soda for Vodka Soda?

When making a Vodka Soda, you'll want a club soda that enhances the vodka's clean taste without adding any extra flavors. Q Club Soda is highly recommended for its high carbonation level and pure taste, which ensures a refreshing and well-balanced cocktail. Canada Dry Club Soda is also a good choice, offering a classic taste and reliable bubbles.

What Soda to Use for Cocktails?

The choice of soda for cocktails depends on the type of cocktail and your flavor preferences. Some popular options include:

• Club Soda: Ideal for simple mixed drinks like Vodka Soda or highballs.
• Tonic Water: Best for gin-based cocktails, such as Gin and Tonic.
• Ginger Beer: Great for cocktails like Moscow Mule or Dark 'n' Stormy.
• Lemon-Lime Soda: Useful in cocktails that require a sweet, citrusy element, like a classic Whiskey Sour or Tom Collins.
• Cola: Perfect for mixed drinks like Rum and Coke or a classic Cuba Libre.

Which is Better, Aperol or Campari?

Choosing between Aperol and Campari depends on your taste preferences and the cocktails you're making:

• Aperol: Known for its lighter, sweeter profile with notes of orange and herbs. It has a lower alcohol content and a more approachable, less bitter flavor, making it ideal for refreshing cocktails like the Aperol Spritz.

• Campari: Offers a more intense, bitter flavor with a deeper complexity. It has a higher alcohol content and is often used in classic cocktails like the Negroni or the Americano. Campari's bold and distinctive taste can add depth to cocktails, but it might be too bitter for some palates.

In summary, Aperol is generally better for those who prefer a sweeter, lighter flavor, while Campari is better for those who enjoy a more robust, bitter profile.

Related Posts:

• Top 10 The Best Sparkling Water
• 10 Best Carbonated Water, best designs
• 10 Best Tasting Sparkling Water Reviewed
• 10 The Best Seltzer Water, Our Top Picks

In the end, the best club soda is the one that hits the right balance of crisp carbonation, clean taste, and versatility—whether you’re mixing cocktails, making mocktails, or just enjoying it straight. While there are several great options out there, the top picks stood out for their consistent fizz, minimal aftertaste, and high-quality ingredients. Whether you’re a casual sipper or a mixology enthusiast, stocking up on a good club soda can seriously level up your drink game.